I gotta say, I agree that I've never listened to a Machinae song and was impressed on the first go (except any instrumental stuff), but I feel like this album was different. I did like a lot of songs the first time I heard it, and I found they were really catchy and kept getting stuck in my head. That started to change though, the few songs I didn't like when I first listened to the album became my favorite songs, and now I'm left with a cd where I don't wanna hear like 70% of the tracks.
It does sound like the production is better than DXM, and I think they sound more like they are playing as a band, and are using every instrument well. What's missing between DXM and Redeemer, I feel, is the guitar...I don't know where it went, the only truly awesome solos are in Kaori Stomp, Hate and Rogue World Asylum (the bass on that song is pretty sweet to). But seriously, I feel like they improved all of the aspects of their music, but dropped the one that was the best in the first place...their extreme guitar virtuosity.
Hopefully it comes back on the next album.
Btw, Through the looking glass is still a great song...but I heard it a million times already.